Browse All Arcadia MI Historical Properties for Sale

6 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1950034 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

This stunning, completely updated, single-family home boasts 6 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and a spacious 3,839 square feet of living space. Situated on the Starkey Road peninsula, this property offers private frontage (two lots) and breathtaking views of Arcadia Lake as well as a short walk to the Starkey Road community shared private Lake Michigan frontage. Dock your boat on your property or use the deep water private marina accessible to all homes on the peninsula. Lake Arcadia connects to the big water of Lake Michigan via the channel to the South. Ample parking and a 2-car attached garage, there is plenty of room for all your vehicles, guests and outdoor toys. Take a short stroll to downtown Arcadia and experience the quaint downtown, local marina and restaurants, which should not be ignored. This property is perfect for enjoying the beauty of the outdoors and local amenities of this picturesque Northern Michigan town. The interior of this home is just as impressive as the exterior, completely remodeled with modern finishes and a floor plan that is perfect for entertaining. Whether you're relaxing in one of two cozy living rooms or cooking a gourmet meal in the chef's kitchen, you'll love every moment spent in this luxurious property. Make no mention of the master suite...it'll make you swoon, you just have to see it!

16643 Starkey Road, Arcadia

$255,000

1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1946419 MLS ⋅ ACTIVE Status

Situated on 1.5 acres, this well-maintained home offers peaceful country living with practical features perfect for year-round comfort or weekend escapes. Inside, enjoy comfortable living spaces filled with natural light, including a bright sunroom—ideal for relaxing, morning coffee, or soaking in the views. The thoughtful layout features 1 bedroom and 2 bathrooms. Outdoor highlights include: - A convenient carport - A spacious pole barn/garage with an established workshop—a fantastic space for projects, storage, hobbies, or small business use The generous lot provides plenty of room for gardening, outdoor activities, or future ideas, all in a quiet, private setting. Nestled along scenic M-22 near Lake Michigan beaches, Arcadia Lake, hiking trails, and Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club. Enjoy boating, fishing, kayaking, and the best of Northern Michigan’s “Up North” lifestyle. Nearby Frankfort and Onekama add charming shops and dining. This versatile property is ideal as a cozy primary home, vacation getaway, or hobbyist haven. Don’t miss this opportunity!

18219 Northwood Highway, Arcadia

$399,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 26009203 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Enjoy life on the water with approximately 103 feet of frontage on the Arcadia Lake canal and direct access to the blue-green waters of Lake Michigan. This inviting home captures both sunrise views toward the Arcadia Marsh and M-22 bridge and sunset views toward the Arcadia pier and Lake Michigan. Inside, you will find warm wood ceilings, expansive windows, and a bright open living space that brings the outdoors in. The updated kitchen, comfortable bedrooms, and spacious deck create the perfect setting for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying Northern Michigan waterfront living. Option to install a permanent dock may exist. Ideally located near Camp Arcadia, Arcadia Marsh Nature Preserve, Arcadia Bluffs, Crystal Mountain, and world-class fishing, hiking, and four-season recreation, this is a great opportunity to enjoy the Arcadia lifestyle.

16864 Northwood Highway, Arcadia

$900,999

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 25031213 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Sand. Water. Memories. A Rare Opportunity on Lower Herring Lake. Tucked into the woods on a full acre with nearly 220 feet of private frontage, this west-facing cottage offers something truly special—a front-row seat to unforgettable sunsets over one of Northern Michigan's best-kept secrets. Lower Herring Lake is a quiet, crystal-clear gem—perfect for kayaking, canoeing, fishing, and water skiing, with abundant wildlife and that ''Pure Michigan'' magic in every direction. Properties like this almost never come to market. Relax with your morning coffee on the deck, listening to the breeze through the trees and the gentle lapping of the shoreline below. Spend your days on the water, and your evenings around the fire as the sun melts into the lake. All just seven miles from the charming shops and restaurants of downtown Frankfort, a short drive to the world-class Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club, and within 20 minutes of Crystal Mountain Resort for four-season fun. A once-in-a-generation chance to own on Lower Herring. Don't let it pass you by.

5002 Herring Grove Road, Arcadia

$795,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 25021080 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Welcome to the Cottage Colony at Camp Arcadia—where Lake Michigan living meets timeless tradition. Nestled in the heart of Arcadia's historic waterfront community, this rare offering features 50 feet of private frontage, a newly installed break wall, and sandy beach access via the Colony Beach Access Park. The home includes four bedrooms, two half baths, and an attached garage with extra storage and a third half bath—perfect for rinsing off after a beach day. Unwind on your deck and take in sweeping views of Lake Michigan's turquoise waters and vibrant sunsets. Ownership includes access to Camp Arcadia's amenities (subject to LCA application and approval), including tennis and basketball courts, playgrounds, beaches, shuffleboard, hiking trails, and moreall part of a community with a peaceful, no short-term rental policy. Just minutes from Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club, Arcadia Marsh Nature Preserve, and world-class trout streamswith Crystal Mountain's year-round recreation close bythis is a unique opportunity to own a piece of Pure Michigan history in a one-of-a-kind lakefront setting.

17646 S Ridgewood Drive, Arcadia

$339,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 25010241 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Rare find in beautiful Arcadia, Mi. Walking distance to the sandy beaches of Lake Michigan, Arcadia lake and the marina. Just off scenic M-22 This home has been a one owner occupied for over 70 years. Hardwood floors and other Updates include vinyl siding, newer windows, roof and the furnace has been replaced less than 2 years ago. 3 bedroom with room for a 4th on the main level with 2 full bathrooms. Large attached garage on a corner lot. This property will be available to show starting 3-21-2-25.

17368 Fourth Street, Arcadia

$1,030,000

11 Baths ⋅ 24062910 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

The Pleasant Valley Resort is looking for its new owners! Located on scenic M-22, just five blocks from Lake Michigan in Arcadia, this thriving resort has been well maintained and continuously improved by the current owners over the past twelve years. 6 clean, cozy motel rooms, and 4 charming cottages offering the conveniences of home, ensure guests enjoy a relaxing stay. With a reliable base of repeat customers who book through the online reservation system each year, this turnkey property equipped with remote check-in capability is ready for a seamless transition to new management. An onsite owners residence gives you the chance to be a part of the Northern Michigan tourist scene, home to beautiful lakes and rivers, hiking trails, and just a short drive from the renowned Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club, ranked among the Top 100 public golf courses nationwide. Additionally, Crystal Mountain offers four-season fun for all ages. This is your opportunity to enjoy the best of Pure Michigan living in a historic and vibrant community.

17229 Northwood Highway, Arcadia

$302,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 24045849 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Just off scenic M22, this quaint and cozy unique home loaded with character must be seen to be appreciated! Detailed interior wood doors and hardwood floors in bedrooms. Numerous updates include: GFA furnace, A/C, electric, paved driveway, new deck and insulation added in garage. Enjoy sitting on deck in back yard with gorgeous varieties of flowers or read on covered front porch while listening to church bells ring on the hour. Just a short walk to Sunset Station Beach or ride your bike to nearby Grebe Park to fish off dock or kayak. Arcadia Marsh/ Boardwalk is also nearby for great walking while enjoying nature. Next to boardwalk: breakfast, lunch, dinner or ice cream...all just 5 minutes from this home. Once you view this comfortable home, you'll want to make Arcadia your home! UTILITIES: Superior: gas (budget plan $80/month) Consumers: electric (budget plan $140/month) Spectrum: internet, tv Northern Disposal ($104 Quarterly) Monday pickup Measurements are approximate. Buyer to confirm measurements.

17332 Third Street, Arcadia

$290,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 50148503 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Country Charm with Modern Comfort! This spacious 3-bed, 2-bath home offers the best of both worlds - a peaceful country setting on 3.33 private acres with the convenience of natural gas heat and central air conditioning (both new!). Unwind on the large new front deck and take in the serene surroundings. Inside, you'll find a fresh, inviting atmosphere with new flooring and paint throughout. Both bathrooms have been beautifully remodeled. Need a home office? This versatile space can easily be used as a formal dining room or even an additional bedroom. For the hobbyist or entrepreneur, the property boasts a dream setup! A massive 50'x75' pole barn provides ample storage and workspace. Plus, a detached 40'x25' garage offers even more options. Enjoy the peace and quiet of country living with the modern conveniences you deserve!

2443 N Lake Pleasant Street, Arcadia

$231,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 24002612 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

This is the one! Great home in great location. The 5 bedroom 1 1/2 bath home is located in the Village of Arcadia with a short walk to Lake Michigan public beach or Arcadia Lake Marina to dock or launch your boat. Arcadia Lake offers boat access to Lake Michigan for some of the best fishing or recreation Northern Michigan has to offer. The large rooms, fenced in yard and 24' x 32' insulated detached garage has room for all your needs. Your a short drive to the Arcadia Bluffs Golf Course, Crystal Mountain Ski & Golf, inland lakes and pristine rivers and streams. You can bike or hike thousands of acres of the Grand Traverse Conservancy or stroll the board walk through the Arcadia Marsh. Here is your chance. As I said this is the one!

17390 Fourth St, Arcadia

$1,065,750

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 23145327 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Adjacent to the renowned Arcadia Bluffs Golf Club, ranked among the Top 100 public golf courses nationwide, this property epitomizes luxury living in one of Michigan's most coveted locales. Nestled atop the majestic bluffs overlooking the pristine shores of Lake Michigan stands this timeless gray cottage, an iconic piece of Arcadia's rich history. Dating back to the 1800s, the cottage exudes charm and character, offering a rare opportunity to own a piece of Arcadia's past. Situated just off the famed M22 scenic highway at the end of picturesque Bischoff Road, this location boasts unparalleled tranquility and natural beauty. Perched within Arcadia Township and zoned as Rural Residence, the possibilities are endless. Whether you envision crafting your custom dream home, establishing a serene retreat for retirement, or embarking on a new entrepreneurial venture with a charming Bed and Breakfast, the choice is yours. With ample land spanning nearly 10 acres, the potential for development is boundless, whether as one expansive estate or subdivided parcels. Upon stepping foot on this enchanting property, prepare to be captivated by its allure and potential. Boasting 408 feet of coveted Lake Michigan frontage, flanked by ravines to the North and South, every corner offers breathtaking vistas of the sapphire-blue waters. Complete seclusion and serenity await, where the only sound is the gentle rustle of the offshore breeze and the star-studded sky casts its mesmerizing glow each night. Immerse yourself in the beauty of Northern Michigan living, where nature's splendor unfolds at every turn. To experience this unparalleled opportunity firsthand, we invite you to explore the property's website at 2710bischoffrd.com, featuring a Virtual Tour, 3D Tour, and captivating drone footage. Additionally, estimates for natural gas hook-up are available, ensuring convenience and comfort for your Lake Michigan retreat.

2710 Bischoff Road, Arcadia

$765,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 23018006 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Own a piece of History in Camp Arcadia with 100 acres of waterfront and wooded property!! Built in 1946 in the Arcadia Cottage Colony with almost 100 ft of water frontage this home has some of the most stunning picturesque views of Lake Michigan from almost every room. Home has three bedrooms, one full and 2 half baths. TWO fireplaces, large deck for great outdoor entertaining and attached garage. There is a $600yr fee which gives you access to all the camp amenities which include, beaches, playground, shuffleboard, hiking trails, tennis, basketball courts baseball field and much more! Close to Point Arcadia. Assoc. does not allow short term rentals. Buyer to verify all sq ft

17696 S Ridgewood Drive, Arcadia

$505,000

9 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 22043711 MLS ⋅ SOLD Status

Always dreamt of living in Northern Michigan & running a business? Opportunity abounds with this B&B in the Village of Arcadia located on the shores of Arcadia Lake & Lake Michigan on M-22 in Manistee County. This historic B&B has currently been run as a VRBO property but ready to go back to B&B with a separate residence for owner/manager. In last 2 years renovated Kitchen, New Game Room, Bunk Room, Outside Dining Area & Fire-pit patio. Arcadia is home to the Arcadia Marsh Wetlands, Arcadia Bluffs acclaimed golf course, Fruit stands all along the famous M-22, hiking & biking trails. All of the Bedrooms have their own bathrooms. All furnishings included in the sale. This a rare opportunity to own a quality business in this area of Michigan. Renovations of the Home in 2021 $46,000 for Kitchen, Game Room, New furniture in Family & Dining Room $24,000 for exterior Fire Table Area, Grill & Exterior Dining Areas Upcoming Rentals 11/18-11/20 and 12/1-12/5

17304 Northwood Highway Unit (M-22), Arcadia

Start Your Search

Arcadia Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Arcadia and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!